Cogpull

11-speed shifter with a 10-speed derailleur

A rear derailleur does not know how many cogs it is moving across: the shifter decides that. What has to match is the derailleur’s ratio — how far it moves per millimetre of cable — with the pull the shifter was designed for. So an 11-speed shifter with a 10-speed derailleur works when both use the same ratio, and the cassette matches the shifter.

Shimano road

Shimano’s 11-speed road shifters and Tiagra 4700 / GRX RX400 10-speed share one derailleur ratio (about 1.4). BikeGremlin states a 4700 derailleur works with Shimano 11-speed road shifters, so an 11-speed lever with a 4700 derailleur runs an 11-speed cassette. The older 10-speed road derailleurs (5700, 6700, 4600) use 1.7 and do not work with 11-speed road shifters, or with 4700 ones.

Shimano mountain

Shimano’s 10- and 11-speed mountain derailleurs both use Dyna-Sys (about 1.15). Shimano charts its dual-speed Deore RD-M5120 and RD-M4120 with both 10- and 11-speed shifters; for other pairs BikeGremlin reports most 11-speed mountain shifters work with 10-speed mountain derailleurs in practice, which the checker shows as a caution. Shimano’s 9-speed mountain derailleurs use the 2:1 ratio and do not work with 10- or 11-speed mountain shifters.

The cassette follows the shifter

Whatever the derailleur, the cassette must have as many cogs as the shifter has clicks: an 11-speed shifter needs an 11-speed cassette. The exception riders use is a converter: Wolf Tooth says a Tiagra 4700 lever goes on a mountain derailleur with its Tanpan 11, an 11-speed mountain derailleur and a 10-speed cassette.

Worked examples

Shimano 105 ST-R7000 + Shimano Tiagra RD-4700-GS + Shimano CS-HG700-11 11-34T

✓ Works

Open this build in the checker

Shimano 105 ST-R7000 + Shimano 105 RD-5701-GS + Shimano 105 CS-R7000 11-28T

✕ Won’t work

Fixes

Open this build in the checker

Shimano Deore SL-M5100-R + Shimano Deore RD-M6000-SGS + Shimano Deore CS-M5100-11 11-42T

✕ Won’t work

Fixes

Open this build in the checker

Shimano Deore SL-M4100-R + Shimano Deore XT RD-M8000-SGS + Shimano Deore CS-M4100-10 11-42T

! Works, with a catch

Open this build in the checker

Check your own parts in the checker; every pull standard and figure is on the cable pull chart.