Cogpull

Mixing Shimano and SRAM

Short answer: Shimano and SRAM cassettes and chains interchange at 8, 9, 10 and 11 speeds, because the cog spacing is the same. Shifters and rear derailleurs mostly do not, because the two makers use different cable-pull ratios. At 12-speed even the cassettes part ways.

Shifters with derailleurs

A shifter pulls a set length of cable per click and a derailleur moves a set distance per millimetre of cable; the two have to agree. Shimano’s road and mountain standards and SRAM’s 1:1, Exact Actuation, X-Actuation and Eagle standards all differ. The table runs every pairing of the main Shimano and SRAM standards through the same rules as the checker, at 11-speed.

SRAM 1:1 (ESP) 7-, 8- and 9-speed derailleurSRAM Exact Actuation (road 10/11-speed, MTB 10-speed) derailleurSRAM X-Actuation 11-speed (MTB) derailleurSRAM Eagle 12-speed (mechanical, X-Actuation) derailleur
Shimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700) shifter✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work
Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed) shifter✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work
Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys) shifter✕ Won’t work✕ Won’t work! Works, with a catch✕ Won’t work
Shimano MTB 12-speed (HYPERGLIDE+) shifter? Not documented? Not documented? Not documented? Not documented

The SRAM-to-Shimano direction is the same picture. The one historical exception is a family of older SRAM derailleurs built for Shimano’s 2:1 pull; BikeGremlin notes they work with Shimano 6- to 9-speed and old road 10-speed shifters, but they are rare now.

Cassettes and chains

Wikibooks’ measurements put Shimano and SRAM cogs at the same spacing from 8- to 10-speed (4.8, 4.35 and 3.95 mm) and within 0.02 mm at 11-speed. So a SRAM PG-1170 cassette works on a Shimano 11-speed road drivetrain, and a Shimano 11-speed chain on a SRAM one, as long as the freehub body fits. At 12-speed Shimano’s cogs are 3.55 mm apart and SRAM Eagle’s 3.65 mm: about a third of a cog over the cassette, and SRAM states Eagle chains are only compatible with SRAM Eagle systems.

Freehub bodies

SRAM’s XD and XDR drivers take only SRAM-standard cassettes (and microSHIFT’s XD ones); Shimano’s Micro Spline takes only Shimano 12-speed mountain cassettes. The HG body is the common ground: Shimano and SRAM HG cassettes from 8- to 10-speed, mountain 11-speed and SRAM’s PG-1230 12-speed all fit it. See freehub bodies.

Converters

Two Jtek ShiftMates bridge the brands: ShiftMate 4 for Shimano and SRAM road 11-speed in either direction, and ShiftMate 6 for Shimano 2:1 shifters with SRAM 1:1 derailleurs.

ConverterShifterDerailleurCassette speedsNotes and source
Wolf Tooth Tanpan 11Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)11Shimano 11-speed road shifter with an 11-speed Shimano mountain derailleur. Wolf Tooth Components, Tanpan (cable pull converter)
Wolf Tooth Tanpan 11Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)10Tiagra 4700 or GRX RX400 10-speed shifter with an 11-speed Shimano mountain derailleur and a 10-speed cassette. Wolf Tooth Components, Tanpan (cable pull converter)
Wolf Tooth Tanpan 10Shimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700)Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)10Shimano 10-speed road shifter (not Tiagra 4700) with a 10-speed Shimano mountain derailleur. Wolf Tooth Components, Tanpan (cable pull converter)
Jtek ShiftMate 8Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)11 Jtek ShiftMate 8
Jtek ShiftMate 8Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)11 Jtek ShiftMate 8
Jtek ShiftMate 6Shimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700)SRAM 1:1 (ESP) 7-, 8- and 9-speed9, 10 Jtek ShiftMate 6
Jtek ShiftMate 6SRAM 1:1 (ESP) 7-, 8- and 9-speedShimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700)9 Jtek ShiftMate 6
Jtek ShiftMate 6Shimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700)Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)8, 9, 10 Jtek ShiftMate 6
Jtek ShiftMate 6Shimano MTB 10- and 11-speed (Dyna-Sys)Shimano 2:1 (6- to 9-speed, and road 10-speed before Tiagra 4700)10 Jtek ShiftMate 6
Jtek ShiftMate 4Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)SRAM Exact Actuation (road 10/11-speed, MTB 10-speed)10, 11 Jtek ShiftMate 4
Jtek ShiftMate 4SRAM Exact Actuation (road 10/11-speed, MTB 10-speed)Shimano road 11-speed (also Tiagra 4700 and GRX RX400 10-speed)11 Jtek ShiftMate 4
Jtek ShiftMate 9SRAM Exact Actuation (road 10/11-speed, MTB 10-speed)SRAM X-Actuation 11-speed (MTB)11SRAM 11-speed road shifter with an SRAM 11-speed mountain derailleur (one way only). Jtek ShiftMate 9

Worked examples

Shimano 105 ST-R7000 + SRAM Rival 22 RD-RIV-B1 + Shimano 105 CS-R7000 11-28T

✕ Won’t work

Fixes

Open this build in the checker

SRAM Rival 22 SB-RIV-B1 + SRAM Rival 22 RD-RIV-B1 + Shimano 105 CS-R7000 11-28T

! Works, with a catch

Open this build in the checker

Shimano Deore XT SL-M8100-R + Shimano Deore XT RD-M8100-SGS + SRAM XG-1295 Eagle XG-1295 10-52T

✕ Won’t work

Fixes

Open this build in the checker

Check your own parts in the checker; every pull standard and figure is on the cable pull chart.